AnswerThisView only
Shared answer · view only
MAShared by Mara Angeline · Oct 13
LoginSign up
Other/I need to know about the relationship between trauma and cognitive difficulties in children and teens
I need to know about the relationship between trauma and cognitive difficulties in children and teens

Trauma exposure is associated with a higher likelihood of cognitive difficulties in children and adolescents—especially in executive functions (working memory, inhibition, flexibility), attention, and learning/memory—but it does not mean every child will have impairment, and the relationship is not uniformly causal. (Malarbi, 2017) (Op Den Kelder, 2018)

What difficulties can look like

Across 55 studies involving 8,070 people aged 2–25, a meta-analysis found small-to-moderate average differences between trauma-exposed and comparison groups in working memory (d = −0.49), inhibition (d = −0.46), and cognitive flexibility (d = −0.44). (Op Den Kelder, 2018) A separate meta-analysis of 27 studies (1,526 participants) found poorer overall cognition among trauma-exposed children than controls (d = −0.57); the largest differences were reported in trauma-exposed children with PTSD, across general intelligence, language/verbal skills, processing, memory, and executive skills. (Malarbi, 2017)

Difficulties may also extend beyond executive skills. In a longitudinal birth-cohort study of 206 children, interpersonal trauma exposure during early childhood was associated with lower IQ scores across repeated assessments, after adjustment for several family and birth factors; exposure in the first two years was associated with scores about half a standard deviation lower on average. (Enlow, 2012) A prospective review of 10 articles (11 studies) likewise found links across several measured domains, including intelligence, executive function, memory, processing speed, reasoning, and academic achievement, but the measures and studies were too heterogeneous to pool. (Su, 2019)

In everyday life, these patterns can show up as trouble holding instructions in mind, sustaining focus, shifting between tasks, remembering new material, or completing schoolwork. Those are plausible functional consequences of the measured cognitive domains, not symptoms that identify trauma by themselves; cognitive difficulties can have many causes. Executive-function differences may be especially relevant to school and social functioning, but the studies do not establish a single profile that applies to every young person. (Deprince, 2009) (Vasilevski, 2016)

What seems to shape the association

Repeated or interpersonal trauma, earlier exposure, and more recent exposure may be associated with greater cognitive risk. A systematic review and meta-analysis of 13 longitudinal studies found poorer overall cognition in children with complex trauma, with trauma timing—particularly recency—moderating the association. (Matte-Landry, 2022) PTSD symptoms also matter: in a meta-analysis of 12 studies, children with post-traumatic stress symptoms had lower executive-function performance than healthy controls (SMD = −0.57), and lower performance than trauma-exposed children without those symptoms (SMD = −0.34). (Nyvold, 2021) But difficulties are not limited to children diagnosed with PTSD; research reviews and studies also report cognitive differences among maltreated or trauma-exposed youth without PTSD. (Malarbi, 2017) (Yasik, 2007)

How certain is the explanation?

The association is well supported, but the size and cause of any individual child’s difficulties are harder to pin down. Poverty, family circumstances, health, prior learning differences, and mental-health symptoms can overlap with trauma exposure. In two birth cohorts, cognitive difficulties in victimized children were largely accounted for by cognitive differences that predated victimization and by shared genetic or environmental risks. (Danese, 2016) A systematic review judged causal evidence strongest for extreme maltreatment in institutionalized children, while findings were less robust in non-institutionalized samples and mixed for specific cognitive functions. (Young-Southward, 2020) Conversely, some prospective studies find that early exposure predicts later cognitive or executive-function outcomes after adjustment for measured factors. (Enlow, 2012) (Den Kelder, 2021) Taken together, trauma can be one contributor to cognitive problems, but a simple “trauma caused the difficulty” conclusion is not justified for every child.

Practical takeaway

If a child or teen exposed to trauma is struggling with attention, memory, learning, or planning, it is reasonable to consider both trauma-related symptoms and a broader assessment of cognitive and educational needs; difficulties should not automatically be attributed to ADHD, low ability, or trauma alone. A review of clinical assessment approaches recommends combining trauma evaluation with assessment of an individual child’s cognitive strengths and weaknesses. (Cook, 2014) This overview is based on retrieved abstracts rather than full-text reading for the cited studies, so detailed methods and study-quality caveats may not be fully assessable.

Follow-up

Save

Citation Lists

Vidanka Vasilevski; Alan Tucker · 2016 · Neuropsychology

Andrea Danese, Terrie E. Moffitt, Louise Arseneault, Benjamin Aaron Bleiberg, Perry B. Dinardo, Stephanie Gandelman, Renate Houts, Antony Ambler, Helen L. Fisher, Richie Poulton, Avshalom Caspi · 2016 · American Journal of Psychiatry

S. Malarbi, S. Malarbi, Hisham M. Abu-Rayya, Frank Muscara, R. Stargatt · 2017 · Neuroscience and Biobehavioral Reviews

Suggested next steps

Run a sensitivity analysisTurn this into a reportAnalyze an uploaded PDFEdit the draftExport the extraction table
TRY:
History

Loading sources…

Q1

I need to know about the relationship between trauma and cognitive difficulties in children and teens

Abstract
Relevant extracts
Source 1: Wide-ranging cognitive deficits in adolescents following early life maltreatment

Vidanka Vasilevski, Alan Tucker · 2016 · Neuropsychology · 46 citations

10.1037/neu0000215

OBJECTIVE: Studies of adolescents with histories of maltreatment typically report specific cognitive deficits in higher order functioning and attention. Emerging evidence suggests that the cognitive difficulties seen in maltreated adolescents are much broader, and go beyond executive functioning impairments. This study examined whether maltreated adolescents exhibited cognitive deficits across a n…

Not available
Source 2: The Origins of Cognitive Deficits in Victimized Children: Implications for Neuroscientists and Clinicians

Andrea Danese, Terrie E. Moffitt, +9 · 2016 · American Journal of Psychiatry · 188 citations

10.1176/appi.ajp.2016.16030333

OBJECTIVE: Individuals reporting a history of childhood violence victimization have impaired brain function. However, the clinical significance, reproducibility, and causality of these findings are disputed. The authors used data from two large cohort studies to address these research questions directly. METHOD: The authors tested the association between prospectively collected measures of childho…

Not available
Source 3: Neuropsychological functioning of childhood trauma and post‐traumatic stress disorder: A meta‐analysis

S. Malarbi, S. Malarbi, +3 · 2017 · Neuroscience and Biobehavioral Reviews · 157 citations

10.1016/j.neubiorev.2016.11.004
Not available

This study reviewed evidence for cognitive impairments in trauma-exposed children with and without PTSD. Twenty-seven studies were eligible for meta-analysis, totalling 1526 participants, including 412 trauma-exposed children (PTSD unknown), 300 children with PTSD (PTSD+), 323 children without PTSD (PTSD-), and 491 trauma-naive controls. Eligible studies mostly investigated familial-maltreatment t…

Source 4: Longitudinal Associations Between Trauma Exposure and Executive Functions in Children: Findings from a Dutch Birth Cohort Study

Rosanne op den Kelder, Alithe L. van den Akker, +6 · 2021 · Research on Child and Adolescent Psychopathology · 10 citations

10.1007/s10802-021-00847-4

This study is the first to distinguish two possible predictive directions between trauma exposure and executive functioning in children in a community sample. The sample consists of 1006 children from two time points with a seven years' time interval of a longitudinal Dutch birth cohort study, the ABCD-study (Van Eijsden et al., 2011). We analyzed the longitudinal associations between trauma expos…

Not available
Source 5: Executive functions in trauma-exposed youth: a meta-analysis

Op den Kelder R, Van den Akker AL, +3 · 2018 · European journal of psychotraumatology · 104 citations

10.1080/20008198.2018.1450595

= -0.44). Moderator analyses showed that, for working memory, when studies used low-quality measurements the effect size was significantly stronger than when studies used high-quality measurements.Compared to single trauma-exposed youth, violence-exposed/abused and foster care/adopted youth showed more problems in inhibition, and foster care/adopted youth showed more problems in cognitive flexibil…

An earlier meta-analysis and review indicated that trauma exposure may be related to lower levels of executive functioning in youth. Since different developmental trajectories were found for three core executive functions, the present study focused on working memory, inhibition, and cognitive flexibility specifically. We conducted a multi-level meta-analysis on 55 studies and 322 effect sizes publ…

Source 6: Neuropsychological Assessment in Clinical Evaluation of Children and Adolescents with Complex Trauma Neuropsychological Assessment and Complex TraumaD. Gabowitz et al. DAWNA GABOWITZ,1 MARLA ZUCKER,2

Alexandra Cook · 2014

Complex trauma (i.e., exposure to chronic, interpersonal trauma in childhood) has been associated with structural and functional alterations in brain development, which in turn can result in cognitive and neuropsychological deficits. The goal of combining neuropsychological assessment with standard trauma specialty evalua-tion is to gain a comprehensive understanding of each child’s unique set of…

Not available
Source 7: Posttraumatic stress disorder: memory and learning performance in children and adolescents

Anastasia E Yasik, Philip A Saigh, +2 · 2007 · Biological Psychiatry · 123 citations

10.1016/j.biopsych.2006.06.005

BACKGROUND: Despite the wealth of information in adult posttraumatic stress disorder (PTSD) literature, few studies have explored the memory and learning performance of trauma-exposed youth. This study examined if memory deficits are associated with PTSD or with trauma exposure in the absence of PTSD. METHODS: Youth exposed to traumatic incidents underwent clinical interviews to diagnose PTSD and…

Not available
Source 8: Executive function performance and trauma exposure in a community sample of children.

Anne P. Deprince, Kristin M. Weinzierl, +1 · 2009 · International Journal of Child Abuse & Neglect · 368 citations

10.1016/j.chiabu.2008.08.002
Not available

OBJECTIVE: Though children exposed to familial violence are reported to have difficulties with a range of emotional and behavioral problems (e.g., lower school achievement) that implicate executive function (EF) deficits, relatively little research has specifically examined EF as a function of trauma exposure in children. METHODS: Based on parent report of children's exposure to potentially trauma…

Source 9: Interpersonal trauma exposure and cognitive development in children to age 8 years: a longitudinal study

Michelle Bosquet Enlow, Byron Egeland, +3 · 2012 · Journal of epidemiology and community health · 135 citations

10.1136/jech-2011-200727

BACKGROUND: Childhood trauma exposure has been associated with deficits in cognitive functioning. The influence of timing of exposure on the magnitude and persistence of deficits is not well understood. The impact of exposure in early development has been especially under-investigated. This study examined the impact of interpersonal trauma exposure (IPT) in the first years of life on childhood cog…

Not available
Source 10: Unity or diversity of executive functioning in children and adolescents with post-traumatic stress symptoms? A systematic review and meta-analysis

Otelie Nyvold, E. Nygaard, +2 · 2021 · Child Neuropsychology: A Journal of Normal and Abnormal Development in Childhood and Adolescence · 16 citations

10.1080/09297049.2021.1979950

ABSTRACT For some children, psychological reactions to a traumatic event develop into severe or persistent post-traumatic stress symptoms (PTSS) or the clinical condition of post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD). Cognitive problems in children with PTSS have been reported, but it is not clear which specific functions are affected. Executive functions is a domain of particular interest, given its i…

For some children, psychological reactions to a traumatic event develop into severe or persistent post-traumatic stress symptoms (PTSS) or the clinical condition of post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD). Cognitive problems in children with PTSS have been reported, but it is not clear which specific functions are affected. Executive functions is a domain of particular interest, given its importance…

13 sources · 0 selected
1 / 2